Emma

Emma

[a Modern Retelling]

Book - 2014
Average Rating:
14
1
Rate this:
An unstoppable combination: Alexander McCall Smith and Jane Austen, as Sandy modernizes the story of Emma Woodhouse.
          Emma Woodhouse's widowed father is an anxious man, obsessed with nutrition and the latest vitamins. He lives the life of a country gentleman in contemporary England, protectively raising his young daughters, Isabella and Emma. While Isabella grows into a young woman, marries a society photographer for Vogue at the age of 19 and gets down to the business of reproducing herself, Emma pursues a degree in interior design at university in Bath, and then returns to set up shop in her home village. With her educated eye for the coordination of pattern and colour, Emma thinks she can now judge what person would best be paired with another, and sets about matchmaking her young friend, Harriet, with various possible suitors. Little does she know she is not the only person encouraging romantic pairings in the village. As Emma's cupid-like curiosity about her neighbours, both young and old, moves her to uncover their deeper motives, she is forced to confront a few surprising truths about her own.
Publisher: Toronto :, Alfred A. Knopf Canada,, c2014
ISBN: 9780345809063
Branch Call Number: FIC McCa
Characteristics: 361 p
Additional Contributors: Austen, Jane 1775-1817:

Opinion

From the critics


Community Activity

Comment

Add a Comment

d
darladoodles
Oct 18, 2017

After reading two of the four books that are part of The Austen Project, I have given up. It is clear that no matter how much we love the stories themselves, they just aren't the same without our beloved Jane telling them.

I know authors like Alexander McCall Smith and others have greatly relished this opportunity, but I am done with this project. The Emma I read about in this retelling was not just a modernized version of Austen's Emma. This Emma is a spoiled, manipulative brat. She blunders around saying tactless things to her neighbors and friends and believes herself to be a virtuous citizen.

What made me like this retelling was the way McCall Smith so neatly tied up most of the loose ends, although there was a big hint about Frank Churchill that was somewhat glossed over and could have been given much more story emphasis.

Don't read this book if you want a Jane Austenesque experience. It just isn't possible. If you are looking for a humorous and entertaining chicklit story, then this book will fit the bill.

JCLChristinD Dec 15, 2016

If you love Alexander McCall Smith, this may be an enjoyable read. If you love Jane Austen, and her Emma, expect to be annoyed. It takes creative re-imagining to make a story about 19th century class and social roles work in a modern setting. It takes wit and charm make the character of Emma work. All of that is lacking here. If you want to see a modern take on Emma that does work, you should definitely watch Clueless.

b
bookmama55
Jun 28, 2016

This was very disappointing . If you love Jane Autin this is a poor remake. This novel was more about Emma's father and he was treated with much more sympathy than Emma who was made to seem a spoiled brat. Granted, she had some growing up to do but the nuances and subtleties of her character was lost with this author. He gave short shift to Emma, but seemed to forgive all the foibles of the vicar and Harriet's characters. The relationship between Emma and Knightley was nonexistent so it made no sense at the end that they loved each other. I am going to retread Jane's Emma to clear my mind.

r
reeread
Feb 20, 2016

Wanted to delay reading this "Emma" until I had read Austen's "Emma". Only read half of the original before I had to read and return Alexander McCall-Smith's version to the library. I always enjoy McCall-Smith's writing and his accurate observations of the nature of his characters, often conveyed with gentle mocking and his "Emma" was no exception. Looking forward to finishing the original.

h
haileyj
Feb 05, 2016

We must remember this is a re-telling of an Austen book so of course the characters will seem "out of touch" with today's world. Even so, Emma was obviously a rich, spoiled girl who thought she was entitled to manage other people's lives even though she herself had no practical experience with love, life and marriage. I didn't like her character mainly because of her sense of entitlement. At the end she does begin to see things a little more realistically. Perhaps this story is more suited for a younger group? I do always enjoy McCall-Smith's writing style so it wasn't too bad.

r
Rosina
Sep 01, 2015

Delightful. An easy read. Typical of Alexander McCall smith. Right from the first page he pokes fun at all society.

j
J9833
Aug 02, 2015

If I had written Emma, I would be disappointed.

Boring and childish, does not translate well into 21st century lifestyle of young women. A waste of good reading time.

b
brangwinn
Jul 13, 2015

The story is nice…what more can I say, but Emma really hasn’t been translated into a modern character. The original Emma is better. I couldn’t like this Emma, she seemed so spoiled.

samdog123 Apr 20, 2015

If it weren't for the fact that Alexander McCall-Smith wrote this book, I don't think I would have finished it. It was a tough slog to get through this modernized version of Austen's 'Emma,' and I don't think the premise of the story transferred itself very well to present day. Thoroughly annoying, Emma is a tough character to identify with and the whole thing just seemed really trite to me. But, if you're an Austen fan, you might enjoy seeing what McCall-Smith has done in this version!

View All Comments

Age Suitability

Add Age Suitability

DanglingConversations thinks this title is suitable for between the ages of 15 and 24

Summary

Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.

Notices

Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.

Quotes

Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number
  Loading...

Find it at NWPL

  Loading...
[]
[]
To Top